As of May 8, 2024, the Trade Bank of Iraq (TBI) officially declared their approval to become one of the banks that engage in salary payments for KRI civil servants (via My Account) in addition to opening ATMs and issuing digital cards for the public sector.1 In a statement provided by CHANNEL8, Iraqi Prime Minister, Mohammed Shia al-Sudani approves of TBI’s support for distributing public wages because of its importance to the people of Iraqi Kurdistan Region. This brief is to shed light on TBI’s history, its financial ratings and the possible reasons behind TBI to support government salary payments.
Prior to this announcement in 2024, the Prime Minister, Ministry of Finance, the Governor of the Central Bank of Iraq, the General Manager of the Bank and several advisors met to discuss and evaluate the performance of the Trade Bank of Iraq (TBI) and to address the problems and challenges it faces.2 In this meeting a road map was confirmed to collect TBI’s bad debts owed by its borrowers. Even though the details of this meeting and how the road map would work are not announced by the bank or any other financial or media entity, there is enough information and data from the international news on this bank, that its status and situation can be evaluated.
Fitch, a credit rating agency, shows the state of TBI and valuates key components that measure the management and operations of the bank. Generally, for a bank to be credit worthy and prove its standalone profile, it needs to receive a Viability Rating from a credit rating agency that is independent and international. On March 11, 2024, Fitch announced its withdrawal of the Viability Rating of Trade Bank of Iraq in addition to downgrading its key ratings. This decision was mainly because of TBI’s dependency on the operations and transactions from the government, which had proven to be unreliable.
Reasons behind the credit rating evaluation3:
Fitch Ratings by Category | Score | Reason | Ratings by Fitch |
Long-Term Issuer Default Rating | ccc+ | Uncertainty of the fulfillment of an issuer’s financial obligations as promised. | Negative |
Government support rating | ccc+ | Unreliable support for the bank | Negative |
Operating-environment | ccc+ | The size and structure of the economy Financial market development | Negative Negative |
Business Profile | ccc+ | Management and governance | Negative |
Earning & profitability | ccc+ | Earnings stability Risk-weight calculation | Negative Negative |
Capital and leverage | ccc+ | Reserve coverage Asset evaluation | Negative Negative |
Funding & liquidity | b- | Deposit structure | Negative |
Viability rating | ccc+ | Decrease in the overall business profile and financial metrics | Withdrawn |
It is worth mentioning that according to the Iraqi Federal Budget 2024, there are two instalments to the TBI account by the Iraqi government which decreased reflecting the liquidity trap.4 One installment is interest paid on treasury transfers from the government expenses according to the Budget Law of 2024, worth 24.2 million U.S. Dollars. The same item on the 2023 Federal Budget was approximately 48.5 million U.S. Dollars. The second instalment is interest paid on treasury transfers to foreign oil companies collectively with Al-Rashid Bank, Al-Rafidain Bank and the Trade Bank of Iraq (TBI), worth approximately 9.8 million U.S. Dollars. The same item on the 2023 Federal Budget was approximately 18.9 million U.S. Dollars.
Trade Bank of Iraq (TBI) is 100% state owned and has been operating since July 2003 in order to facilitate trade finance, and it is dominating 20% of the market share in the banking sector. Since Trade Bank of Iraq (TBI) is a state-owned bank, it reflects the fluctuations in national revenue in the common pools (also known as national banks). The interest payments to the bank are not timely, therefore the bank is considered financially risky. There are usual liquidation traps due to internal political conflicts and the government needs to better manage the overall payments to the bank. The question at hand is not whether this bank supports “My Account” for distributing public wages in Iraqi Kurdistan Region (KRI), however, it is whether this bank is financially safe for distributing public wages? It is likely, as some of the evidence points to, that the Government of Iraq is attempting to help raise TBI’s credibility and rating to an acceptable level while using the bank to facilitate the distribution of salaries of civil servants in KRI.